this is not me

   

Pomona College
Department of Philosophy

Pearsons 209
551 N. College Avenue
Claremont, CA 91711
electronic mail: peter.kung@pomona.edu

« artwork by the talented Ray Buchanan
   
   
R e s e a r c h
specialization

My areas of specialization are philosophy of mind and epistemology; other interests include metaphysics and history of philosophy (particularly modern philosophy).

interests

I am currently working on conceivability and possibility; it's a topic that's at the intersection of my two main areas of interest (mind and epistemology). This was the topic of my dissertation, "Imagination and Modal Epistemology," which I did at New York University.

Tradition has it that conceivability is the evidence for possibility that gets us to this modal knowledge. But what is conceivability? I think it's obvious that 'conceive' cannot mean think, understand, entertain, suppose, or find believable, because none of these are suited to serve as evidence for possibility. And if it is none of these, it is mysterious what conceivability is, and why it is evidence for possibility. I argue that sensory imagination is the most promising candidate for a source of modal evidence. A crucial part of this argument is devising an answer to this challenge by Paul Tidman:

How do you know you are having the right sort of image for making judgments concerning possibility? Is there any way of distinguishing mental images from which it is safe to infer possibility from those from which it is not? It is difficult to see how this might be done. (Tidman, P. [1994]. Conceivability as a test for possibility. American Philosophical Quarterly , 31[4], 299)

I see the project as consisting of several components:

  • Theory of sensory imagination – The theory of sensory imagination I develop draws on recent work on the content of perceptual experience. As a methodological point, I think it's crucial that we not "rig" the theory of imagination to fit our views about possibility.

  • Modal epistemology – The crux of the project is to explain why sensory imagination counts as evidence for possibility in such a way that I can offer a principled answer to Tidman's challenge. What I call assignments are the key: imaginings in the suspect category are those that rely exclusively on assignments; in slogan form, “assignments make imagining the impossible possible.” I argue that the view neatly handles some of the puzzle cases in the literature, such as a posteriori necessities and zombie cases prominent in the modal arguments for dualism.

  • First-Person Perspective – Imagination comes in both a third-person ("from the outside") and a first-person ("from the inside") variety, and this difference is critical in some mind-body dualism thought experiments. I find first-person imagining extremely puzzling, and explore it in connection with perception and memory.

  • Alternative Sources of Modal Evidence – Part of securing a prominent place for imagination in modal epistemology is showing that other putative sources cannot provide the same results.

 
E d u c a t i o n
Ph.D., Philosophy

New York University, Department of Philosophy

Dissertation: "Imagination and Modal Epistemology"
Committee: Ned Block (adviser), Paul Boghossian, Thomas Nagel

A.M., Philosophy Stanford University, Department of Philosophy
B.S.E., Computer Science & Engineering

University of Pennsylvania, Department of Computer Science

 
T e a c h i n g

Spring 2007
Pomona College

Advanced Seminar: Psychology and Computation (Phil 185L, with Masahiro Yamada)
Epistemology (Phil 81)

Fall 2006
Pomona College

Knowledge, Mind and Existence (Phil 30, with Brian Keeley), Spring 2006
Objectivity: is the truth out there? (ID1)

previous courses
Pomona College

Knowledge, Mind and Existence (Phil 30, with Brian Keeley), Spring 2006
Advanced Seminar: the Skeptical Challenge (Phil 185L, with Masahiro Yamada), Spring 2006

Philosophy of Mind (Phil 80), Fall 2005
Exploring the Mind and the Self (ID 1), Fall 2005

Advanced Seminar: Conceivability and Possibility (Phil 185L), Spring 2005
Problems of Philosophy (Phil 1), Spring 2005

Manifest Image vs. Scientific Image (ID 1), Fall 2004
Knowledge, Mind and Existence (Phil 30), Fall 2004

previous courses
NYU

Epistemology, Spring 2004, Summer 2003 (with Greg Epstein)
History of Modern Philosophy, Spring 2003
Philosophy of Mind, Fall 2003, 2002
Philosophy of Mind: Summers 2000, 1999
Introduction to Philosophy: Summers 2002, 2000, 1997
History of Modern Philosophy: Summer 1998

assistant teaching
NYU

Philosophy of Science, Professor Gordon Belot, Spring 2001
Ethics and Society, Professor Albert Piacente, Fall 2000
History of Modern Philosophy, Professor John Gibbons, Spring 2000
Introduction to Philosophy, Professor Barbara Montero, Fall 1999
 
C o n f e r e n c e s
University of California, Riverside
April 2004

“Imagination and Possibility”

University of California, Irvine
October 2004

9th Southern California Philosophy Conference
“Imaginability as a Guide to Possibility”

Vrije Universiteit (Free University)
July 2004

Conference on Knowledge and Imagination
"Imagining, Inside and Out "

Harvard-MIT
March 2003
"How to Avoid Modal Error,"
commentator: Josh Sheptow, University of California, Berkeley
Oxford
October 2001
"Imagination and Possibility,"
commentator: Professor Bill Brewer, St. Catherine's College Oxford
Berkeley-Stanford
April 1997
"Externalism and Closure"
 
P e r s o n a l
My sister Tana’s wedding! Ye Ye
in memoriam